The acquisition of Opengear by Digi International


Logo-with-Text

Three years ago, I joined Opengear as CTO, with a mission of setting strategies for company growth. For me, it was like jumping into a time machine and having a second take in the market space I helped to create 20 years earlier with Cyclades. Over this period, Opengear multiplied investments in product and technology, doubled revenues and profits, captured new opportunities, and projected a vision that turned a cash-cow business into a vibrant growth story and reality.

Today, we are announcing Opengear will become part of Digi International, in a cash transaction of $140M + $15M, expressing the value of work by founders and contributors over the last 15 years. This marks the end of a cycle and sets a path forward as part of a larger publicly-traded company.

Digi and my career have been intertwined for the past 30 years. I have seen Digi as an aspirational reference, collaborator, partner, customer, and competitor over the last three decades. Once the transaction closes, I hope to contribute to the company efforts to deliver solutions, project vision and capture market value in the industrial IoT and Network Management markets.

I am grateful for the opportunity and outcome at Opengear, and remain curious on what the future will bring.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/digi-international-to-acquire-opengear-300954304.html

Let’s Grab Coffee


I believe in random encounters. I believe in free exchanges. But, because of professional context, a lot of people ask me to “grab a coffee”. I just cannot do it with everyone who asks.

Meeting someone takes work and time. I prepare to meet people and follow-up on meetings.

Your request is not random, you want my time for something of your interest. So, before I give you a couple of hours of my time, spend a fraction of that to tell me what your interest is about and how I can participate or help.

If you are trying to sell me something (a product, a service, a project, an idea)… Make sure I am a good potential buyer. Write a compelling summary of what that is.

If you are seeking my opinion or advice… I like to and often share my thoughts and experiences with others. Make sure you know the questions you want me to answer and read what I have already written on the subject. When you contact me, provide enough context for me to judge whether or not I can help.

If you want a favor… Why should I help? Am I contributing to a better world? Am I somehow unique in the ability to help? Why me?

If you are an entrepreneur and want to meet me, but doesn’t have any specific request, then meet me at one of the events involving the entrepreneurship community in the SF Bay Area.

If you just want access to my network of relationships because someone told you I am well-connected… I am not. And relationships are inherited through relationships, you cannot access mine without being part of the network. Build your own relationships, one person at a time.

Thanksgiving and meaning it


This week is the time of the year when we in the US take a break from our busy lives to express Gratitude. I have plenty to be thankful for this year.

Gratitude is a positive emotion we feel in acknowledgment of a benefit we have received. Saying “Thank You” is the way to express that emotion which is the basis of life in community. It recognizes that we depend on one another to live, to be ourselves.

We get used to say “Thank You” as a matter of social protocol. This is the time to bring its meaning back to consciousness.

In my native Portuguese, we say “Obrigado“, which is not my favorite expression because it equals gratitude with indebtedness. Literally, it says “I owe you something”.

In my travels around the world I have always taken interest not only on the local word to express gratitude, but also on its literal meaning and the social attitude behind it.

My favorite form of “Thank You” is the one used in Malaysia. “Terima Kasih” sounds very friendly and it literally translates to “Receive Love”.

I am no historian or linguist, but I theorize that words equating gratitude and indebtedness have roots in a period in history where gratitude was used as social currency between levels of hierarchy, where favors were exchanged for political loyalty. Words that equals gratitude with love reflect a more equal exchange between peers.

As we evolve towards a world where stronger relationships are people-to-people rather than people-to-organization, gratitude has to be more like love and less like indebtedness.

With that in mind, I would like to say Thank You for reading, agreeing or disagreeing, providing feedback and teaching me through interaction this year.

Here is a list to say Thank You in other languages.

Happy Thanksgiving.

The Launch of Graava


In 2015-2016, I joined Graava, a startup project designing a consumer camera.

On Aug 5th, 2015 we run what was arguably the most successful (from a media exposure perspective) marketing launch for a crowdfunding HW project to date. We were hoping for significant coverage, but what we got surpassed all expectations. Graava was featured in every major mainstream and technology media outlet, including TechCrunch, Wired, Forbes, The New York Times. We were also on broadcast TV a few times. A partial (but impressive) list of links to coverage is below.

So, why did the Graava project eventually fail? (of course, this is just my personal analysis).

Graava was ahead of a wave and identified and proposed a solution for a real problem: automate the edition of video footage using data and AI. GoPro, Google, Apple among other have later introduced similar capabilities in their platforms. We selected to launch a hardware product because of the appeal of a physical device.

Graava was part of a broader market experiment with using crowdfunding to validate the demand for a hardware consumer product, and then using that validation to raise venture capital to produce and deliver the product. That model has failed.

Graava raised a couple million dollars in seed money from angel investors and built a camera (I have pre-production units), but failed to raise the additional funding necessary to bring the product to market. It returned all the funds from the crowdfunding campaign to the users, switched to focus in software and launched an IOS/Android App in 2016 that delivered the same functionality using smartphones. The App was featured in the Apple store, but failed to gain the traction needed to create a viable business model. The project was discontinued later in 2016.

Pebble was probably the earliest and arguably the most successful example in the consumer HW/crowdfunding model. They were early in the smartwatch wave and actually delivered a couple of generations of products before going under. Post-Graava, late in the cycle, Lily is said to have sold 60,000 drones (at $500-$1000 each) and raised $15M from major VC firms before failing without delivering a product. Between those two, a long list of projects also failed. Coin and Navdy are two high-profile examples.

Our launch video (produced by Sandwich video):

Video Media Coverage:

ABC7 News interviewed us for the evening news. See video.

TechCrunch interviewed us for the launch. See video.

TechCrunch Crunch Report also featured us. See video (6 min mark).

We were on prime time broadcast TV also in Brazil: See video.

Online and Print Media Coverage:

The New York Times – A New Action Camera, Born From a Cycling Crash

Wired Magazine –  This self-editing action camera is the future of video

NBC News – Graava Action Camera Edits Your Footage For You

Forbes – Watch Out GoPro, This Camera Promises To Edit Your Video For You

TechCrunch – A $249 Action Camera That Edits Highlight Videos For You

Fast Company – GRAAVA’S NEW CAMERA EDITS YOUR VIDEOS FOR YOU

Fast Company Design –  A smart action cam for who don’t want to edit

Mashable – Editing video is hard. Let the Graava action camera do it for you

The Verge – Graava is a new action camera that does the editing for you

VentureBeat – Graava video camera uses A.I. to automatically edit your video footage

Apple Insider – Graava camera edits its own footage using onboard sensors, Apple Watch and cloud processing

Yahoo News! – Graava camera captures and edits videos automatically

CNET – Graava camera promises to capture, edit and share your best moments

Popular Science – GRAAVA ACTION CAMERA EDITS YOUR VIDEO

GQ – CAMERA GRAAVA : VOUS FILMEZ, ELLE GÈRE LE MONTAGE

PC Magazine – Meet Graava, an Action Cam That Edits Videos for You

PC World – Graava action cam automatically finds best clips

Uncrate – GRAAVA ACTION CAMERA

Re/code – Editing Makes Good Videos Great. Can Computers Do It Better Than Humans?

Gizmag – Graava actioncam promises videos that are all killer, no filler

The Next Web – Graava camera will automatically capture and edit your tedious holiday videos

Digital Trends – If only your GoPro could edit its own footage like this smart camera

Crowdfund Insider – GoPro Killer? Graava Video Camera Uses Artificial Intelligence to Keep the Best, Tosses the Rest

9to5 Toys – The new Graava action camera uses your heartbeat to capture the best moments and make a highlight reel

SlashGear – Graava action cam auto-creates highlight reels

Ubergizmo – Graava Action Cam Takes The Pain Out Of Editing Videos

Photo District News – Graava Camera Uses Artificial Intelligence and Sensors to Edit Video for You

Shutterbug – Unique New Graava Camera Uses Artificial Intelligence to Self Edit Videos

Indirect / Syndications / International:

MSN – Graava Action Camera Edits Your Video, So You Don’t Have To

MSN – Graava Captures And Edits Video Footage

Techmeme – Graava is an action camera that automatically edits your video and prepares highlights, on preorder for $249, to eventually retail for $399  

Aol Tech – Graava Captures And Edits Video Footage

Computerworld – Graava action cam automatically finds best clips

CIO – Graava action cam automatically finds best clips

BGR – Graava is the newest action camera in the block that can edit your videos for you

Pocket-lint – Graava action cam is more like a sensor-loaded smart cam that can edit your vids

Peta Pixel – Graava is a Smart Action Camera That Can Edit Your Footage For You

Mac Stories – Graava Action Camera and watchOS 2

The Tech Bulletin – $249 Graava camera edits Highlight videos

Geeky Gadgets – Graava Smart Life Logging Camera Now Available To Pre-Order For $249 (video)

Gizmoids – THIS NEW GRAAVA ACTION CAMERA WILL ALSO DO THE EDITING FOR YOU

Poker News – GRAAVA’S NEW ACTION CAMERA EDITS VIDEO FOR YOU. YES. IT DOES.

Motoroids – Graava’s new action camera can also edit videos for you

Engine vs. Motor – Graava action camera edits videos for you

Demanjo News – Graava Is A $249 Action Camera That Edits Highlight Videos For You

Food World News – Go Pro Competitor ‘Graava’: This New Toy Edits Videos For you

Argyll Life Press GRAAVA ACTION CAM DOES ALL THE EDITING FOR YOU

Yibada – Graava Camera‘s AI Automatically Picks, Synthesizes Top Video Clips

Tulane Hullabaloo – Graava camera captures and edits videos automatically; preorder price $249

Uber Topic – Graava Is A $249 Action Camera That Edits Highlight Videos For You

IDG Blog – Rival da GoPro: nova câmera usa IA para editar vídeos dos usuários

Technoblog – Feita por brasileiros: conheça a Graava, a câmera que edita os vídeos por você

wwwhats news – Graava, cámara de acción inteligente que captura momentos concretos

Apparata –Betaalbare action cam monteert automatisch je video’s

Xataka – Las cámaras de acción de Graava editan los vídeos por ti

  1. http://t3n.de/news/action-cam-graava-action-kamera-628944/
  2. http://www.nu.nl/gadgets/4101520/nieuwe-actiecamera-graava-monteert-zelf.html
  3. http://webrazzi.com/2015/08/06/graava-aksiyon-kamerasi/
  4. http://www.journaldugeek.com/2015/08/06/la-camera-graava-soccupe-seule-du-montage-video/
  5. http://www.sciencealert.com/this-gopro-style-action-cam-automatically-edits-your-videos-so-you-don-t-have-to
  6. http://playtech.ro/2015/graava-action-cam-iti-editeaza-automat-filmele-din-vacanta/
  7. http://rsfotografia.pt/noticias/cameras/graava-uma-camera-de-acao-inovadora/
  8. http://olhardigital.uol.com.br/noticia/camera-usa-inteligencia-artificial-para-editar-videos-automaticamente/50308
  9. http://br.ccm.net/news/26706-camera-edita-com-inteligencia-artificial
  10. http://jp.techcrunch.com/2015/08/06/20150805graava-camera/
  11. http://www.donanimhaber.com/video-kameralar/haberleri/Duzenleme-isini-kendi-halleden-aksiyon-kamerasi-Graava.htm
  12. http://www.bright.nl/deze-actiecamera-monteert-zelf-de-tofste-momenten-aan-elkaar
  13. http://www.fastweb.it/smartphone-e-gadget/graava-l-action-cam-che-modifica-i-video-automaticamente/
  14. http://www.computerworld.com.pt/2015/08/06/imagem-do-dia-camara-de-video-com-auto-edicao/
  15. http://www.newindianexpress.com/lifestyle/tech/Graava-Camera-Captures-And-Edits-Videos-Automatically/2015/08/06/article2960708.ece
  16. http://www.baybrazil.org/bruno-gregory-marcelo-do-rio-marcio-saito-co-founders-of-graava
  17. http://siliconrus.com/2015/08/graava/
  18. http://www.supercompressor.com/tech/graava-action-camera-lets-you-record-edit-and-share-your-videos-best-action-cameras
  19. http://www.thewiire.com/technology/graava-action-camera-that-automatically-captures-best-clips/6142/
  20. http://designtaxi.com/news/378483/The-Compact-Graava-Rivals-The-GoPro-Picks-Out-And-Edits-Your-Best-Footage/
  21. http://www.loopjamaica.com/content/video-check-out-self-editing-camera-graava
  22. http://www.praquempedala.com.br/blog/graava-camera-que-usa-inteligencia-artificial-para-filmar-e-editar-videos-para-voce/
  23. http://thetechblock.com/graava-let-graava-save-your-best-memories/?comments=1
  24. https://macmagazine.com.br/2015/08/05/graava-e-uma-camera-criada-por-brasileiros-que-utiliza-sensores-para-editar-videos-automaticamente/
  25. http://theupscout.com/tech/graava-action-cam/
  26. http://jovemnerd.com.br/nerd-news/graava-e-uma-nova-camera-que-faz-a-edicao-por-voce/
  27. http://www.computerbild.de/artikel/avf-News-Video-Graava-ActionCam-Videoschnitt-automatisch-12555397.html
  28. http://appleapple.top/action-camera-graava-relieve-the-user-from-the-need-to-mount-video/
  29. https://lockerdome.com/6293523053947457/7915635833312532
  30. http://wwwhatsnew.com/2015/08/05/graava-camara-de-accion-inteligente-que-captura-momentos-concretos/
  31. http://hiconsumption.com/2015/08/graava-action-camera/
  32. http://www.pcworld.idg.com.au/article/581342/graava-action-cam-automatically-finds-best-clips/
  33. http://bismannews.rrvnews.com/item/35806_editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you
  34. https://socialmediablazer.com/2015/08/graava-is-a-249-action-camera-that-edits-highlight-videos-for-you/4126454.html
  35. https://in.news.yahoo.com/graava-camera-captures-edits-videos-automatically-085922189.html
  36. http://www.geekwire.com/2015/more-pro-than-a-gopro-this-camera-claims-to-edit-video-for-you/
  37. http://techno-stream.net/graava-camera-promises-to-capture-edit-and-share-your-best-moments/
  38. http://hifipublic.com/2015/08/06/graava-the-new-action-cam-that-can-also-edit-videos/
  39. http://newsyac.com/2015/08/05/graava-action-cam-edits-your-footage-for-you/
  40. http://www.mansworld.co/socialpost/3364603/editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you
  41. http://iamyouth.me/editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you/
  42. http://www.cio.co.nz/slideshow/581342/graava-action-cam-automatically-finds-best-clips/
  43. http://techpaper.org/social/graava-is-a-249-action-camera-that-edits-highlight-videos-for-you/
  44. http://www.superspider.tk/graava-action-camera-edits-your-footage-for-you-nbcnews-com/
  45. https://www.aruco.com/2015/08/graava-camera/
  46. http://www.qore.com/noticias/39404/Graava-la-camara-de-accion-que-hace-todo-el-trabajo-rudo-por-ti
  47. http://fullnoticias.web.ve/2015/08/06/graava-la-camara-que-edita-tus-videos/
  48. http://www.giga.de/digitalkamera/graava/
  49. http://www.want.nl/de-graava-actiecamera-edit-beelden-tot-actiefilm-vol-hoogtepunten-voor-jou/
  50. http://mmc-news.com/news-graava-action-camera-edits-your-footage-for-you-76129.dbv
  51. http://www.ifanr.com/549177
  52. http://marcogomes.com/blog/2015/lancamento-graava-a-1a-camera-que-usa-sensores-e-inteligencia-artificial-para-editar-videos-automaticamente/
  53. http://www.macstories.net/ios/graava-action-camera-and-watchos-2/
  54. http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/video-camera-uses-artificial-intelligence-to-automatically-edit-footage-080615.html
  55. http://www.medyaloji.net/son-haber/graavadan-fantastik-aksiyon-kamerasi_23638194.html
  56. http://japan.cnet.com/news/service/35068479/
  57. http://www.bnext.com.tw/video/view/id/121
  58. http://www.ctimes.com.tw/DispNews-tw.asp?O=HJZ86AXHWY4SAA00NS
  59. http://techcrunch.com/video/facebook-launches-livestreaming-video-crunch-report/518992657/
  60. https://nplus1.ru/news/2015/08/06/graava
  61. http://hitech.newsru.com/article/06aug2015/graava
  62. http://www.stuff.tv/mx/noticias/graava-es-la-camara-que-graba-y-edita-por-ti
  63. http://www.gadgette.com/2015/08/06/graava-action-cam/
  64. http://technabob.com/blog/2015/08/06/graava-automatic-action-camera/
  65. http://www.infotechnology.com/negocios/Graava-la-camara-del-estilo-GoPro-que-edita-tu-video-de-forma-automatica-20150806-0001.html
  66. http://www.t3me.com/en/news/cameras/graava-action-cam-edits-footage-you
  67. http://www.ihomeidea.com/editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you/
  68. http://macradar.ru/ilajk/graava-ekshen-kamera-kotoraya-zapisyvaet-tolko-chto-dejstvitelno-nuzhno/
  69. http://www.addiehf.com/2015/08/editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you.html
  70. http://news.thaiware.com/6668.html
  71. https://thatsmart.ru/2015/08/249-and-it-will-eventually-retail-for-399/
  72. http://www.tec.com.pe/graava-la-camara-inteligente-que-edita-los-videos-por-ti/
  73. http://www.spidersweb.pl/2015/08/graava.html
  74. http://uapress.info/uk/news/show/89649
  75. http://arts.re-publish.com/137743/editing-video-is-hard-let-the-graava-action-camera-do-it-for-you
  76. http://bylines.news.yahoo.co.jp/taromatsumura/20150806-00048235/
  77. http://www.spendingitall.com/graava-action-camera/
  78. http://thegadgetflow.com/portfolio/graava-action-camera-that-does-the-editing-for-you/

How to think about my startup valuation?


valuation

I often get this question from early stage entrepreneurs: “How do I calculate the valuation of my startup?”

The valuation of a startup is the value of the company at the moment when the first round of venture capital is raised. Valuation should not be the focus of the early stage entrepreneur. For more on that, please read on.

Am I ready to talk to a VC?

If VC’s are willing to talk to you, go ahead and talk to them. But the conversation will have tangible consequences only if your startup is at the stage of development for a VC capital investment.

You are ready to raise VC funding when at least one of the following conditions are satisfied:

  • Users – Your B2C service has millions of users and that number is growing exponentially through social propagation. The target audience is everyone in the world. There is no business model, but who cares? You are the next Instagram.
  • Traction – Your project has a significant number of users (hundreds of thousand for B2C, several customers for B2B) and at least one business model for monetization has been validated (advertisement, commission, subscription, sales, etc.). Your startup is not a website, it is a business.
  • Innovation – Your project includes  Innovation with uppercase “I”, that is applicable to the solution of a high-value concrete problem. The innovation is either protected by patent or is very difficult to replicate. You’ve invented teleporting.
  • Resume – You have a well-formed project and a team that has previously created other companies that were successful and generated return to investors. Those investors are willing to offer capital even before the previous criteria are satisfied.

The details of the criteria above might vary slightly from a VC to another, but there is no magic. Note that VCs are professional investors investing capital from a fund that received money from other investors. The VC investor does not own the money and can only invest if they can model it based on the goals of the fund.

Seed Money

If none of the criteria above is satisfied, the valuation of your startup has no valuation.

But that should not be cause for alarm. It is the case of the vast majority of the startups. It doesn’t mean the project is wrong or has no future. It only means you need to execute further before its value creates a valuation.

If you need capital to execute before there is a valuation, you will need seed money, normally a smaller amount enough to run the company for a few months, provided by an Angel Investor.

While it is fun to guess numbers, there is usually no need to define a valuation to raise seed money. The angel investor usually receives convertible notes in exchange for the investment. Simply put, a convertible note is a loan denominated in dollars (often including interest and discount clauses) that is converted in equity participation if and when there is a first round of venture capital investment (when a more concrete valuation is defined by a professional investor).

Ok, got it. But what if I still want to guess what valuation I can get for my company?

The definition of a valuation at the raising of venture capital will take in account the structure of ownership (how many founders, how many key people) and the amount to be raised (which is a function of the money needed to execute as well as the preferences of the fund).

The investor must believe in the project and the team, so it has vested interest in keeping the team committed and motivated. There is no incentive to squeeze the entrepreneurs by defining valuation that is too low. So the actual valuation is based on real market perceptions, but ends up being a number that makes the round viable and a win for all parties involved.

Now, if after all this discussion, you really want to estimate a possible valuation, you can try at least three different approaches:

  • Financial – If you have a solid business plan, valuation can be calculated based on the execution risk and the projections of revenue and profit and a possible sale or IPO. Because execution risks in early stage are very high, it is virtually impossible to achieve much confidence in a number. Normally, the investors try to model this, not the entrepreneur.
  • Market – VC investments usually become public information. You can estimate your valuation based on the valuation of similar companies in similar stages of execution that are receiving professional investment.
  • Opportunity Cost – Calculate the amount of the time and effort applied to the project and estimate what would be its value if that effort was applied in a well established business. This is the cost of opportunity of your project. This number is irrelevant to the investor, but can be useful for the entrepreneur to continuously monitor the viability of the project (the cost of opportunity must be always below the valuation one hopes to achieve in the future).

Thanksgiving 2013


It is again that time of the year when we in the US take a break from our busy lives to express Gratitude (and eat, shop, etc).

Gratitude is a positive emotion we feel in acknowledgment of a benefit we have received. Saying “Thank You” is the way to express that emotion which is the basis of life in community. It recognizes that we depend on one another to live, to be ourselves.

We get used to say “Thank You” as a matter of social protocol. This is the time to bring its meaning back to consciousness.

I grew up in Brazil and my native language is Portuguese. We say “Obrigado“, which is not my favorite expression because it equals gratitude with indebtedness. Literally, it says “I owe you something in exchange for this”.

In my travels around the world I have always taken interest not only on the local word to express gratitude, but also on its literal meaning and the social attitude behind it.

My favorite form of “Thank You” is the one used in Malaysia. “Terima Kasih” sounds very friendly and it literally translates to “Receive Love”.

I am no historian or linguist, but I theorize that words equating gratitude and indebtedness have roots in a period in history where gratitude was used as social currency between levels of hierarchy, where favors were exchanged for political loyalty. Words that equals gratitude with love reflect a more equal exchange between peers.

As we shift towards a world where stronger relationships are more equal and transparent, gratitude has to be more like love and less like indebtedness.

With that in mind, I would like to say Thank You for reading, agreeing or disagreeing, providing feedback and teaching me through interaction in 2013.

Here is a list to say Thank You in other languages.

Happy Thanksgiving.